David Biale: Cultures of the Jews Volume 1 Mediterranean Origins

EBOOK BOOK Cultures of the Jews Volume 1 Mediterranean Origins by David Biale – chernov–art.com

Nothing specific to each subdivision makes you wonder besides inding the authors and writing a Another Day of Life few pages what does it mean that Biale was the editorThe book also assumes that you know uite a bit of both the history of the Jews and of Judaism While this project was originally intended to be a definitive and modern history of Judaismor an educated audience of non scholars that book stills need to be written The closest and best although it s outdated and sadly out of print that comes close is Daniel Jeremy Silver s History of JudaismAfter a break I ll move on to Volume 2 Hopefully with sources the uality will improvePS my comment below is really an earlier and less well edited version of this reviewI clicked on wrong thingee and it didn t a comment instead of a review So yes you can skip it. And assumed new What Would You Like? forms in response to the cultural environment in which the Jews have lived Mediterranean Origins theirst volume in Cultures of the Jews describes the concept of the “People” or “Nation” of Israel that emerges in the Hebrew Bible and the culture of the Israelites in relation to that of neighboring Canaanite groups It also discusses Jewish cultures in Babylonia in Palestine during the Greco Roman and Byzantine periods and in Arabia during the ormative years of Isl.


Hapter on Arabian Jewry is eually mediocre although rom almost the opposite extreme it takes uranic Hadith accounts of early Islam Arabia almost as canonical history tries to understand Arabian Jewry based on that Cinderella for a Night (36 Hours, false assumption Having read Tom Holland s amazing book on this period I can t take that chapter too seriouslyThe best chapters were the ones on the Second Temple Roman rule and Babylonian Jewry Lots of interesting insights and new ideasWhile understanding the structure is it too much to ask that Biale do some editing to ensure consistency of terminology like the anachronistic use of the name Palestine to describe the area can drive you crazy why would a historian not use contemporaneous names Plus theact that the introduction and conclusion are rom the one volume edition with. Specific cultural artifacts that were created in the period and locale under study the contributors describe the cultural interactions among different Jews–from rabbis and scholars to non elite groups including women–as well as between Jews and the surrounding non Jewish world What they conclude is that although Jews have always had their own autonomous traditions Jewish identity cannot be considered the ixed product of either ancient ethnic or religious origins Rather it has shifted.

This book strength is also it s weakness it is a collection of disparate essays The Longevity Diet from various authors not a coherent presentation of Jewish history On the one hand that provides an opportunity to present multiple viewpoints that one author or a strongly edited book wouldn t On the other hand there are huge gaps in the story nothing on Alexandrian Jewryor which we have written contemporaneous sources Philo anyone annoying inconsistencies in terminology and vast differences in uality depth and interest between chapter to chapterSo one of the worst chapters is that on the Biblical period it s a hermeneutic interpretation of the bible rather than a cultural history of the period based on archeological evidence You won t Grassroots Innovation find any judgement here on the historical veracity of the Bible The last Scattered over much of the world throughout most of their history are the Jews one people or many How do they resemble and how do they differrom Jews in other places and times What have their relationships been to the cultures of their neighbors To address these and similar uestions some of the inest scholars of our day have contributed their insights to Cultures of the Jews a winner of the National Jewish Book Award upon its hardcover publication in 2002Constructing their essays around.